One Nation, One King
- Demetrios Matheou
- 21 January 2019
The French revolution is the subject of an intelligent but insufficiently stirring epic
Quickly following Mike Leigh's Peterloo is an account of the early years of the French revolution that also honours working men and women fighting for change. And, like Peterloo, it's a predominantly talky affair – intelligent and absorbing, but not particularly stirring. One shouldn't expect the panache usually associated with French period drama.
Writer-director Pierre Schoeller opens with the storming of the Bastille in July 1789 and the creation of the National Assembly, moving towards the formation of the Republic a few years later and the execution of King Louis XVI. There's very little action, with the taking of the Bastille and other violent confrontations occurring off screen. There is one exception: a massacre of demonstrators ordered by the Assembly itself, a bitter presage of the Reign of Terror and the murderous infighting to come. The introduction of the guillotine will send a shiver down the spine.
Most of the film is spent on lengthy debate, with a fascinating difference of opinion between the working poor, who are inclined to drive the revolution forward until they win palpable rights – and food on the table – and the upper classes who preside over the Assembly but whose radicalism has its limits. 'Without Louis,' observes one, 'the edifice crumbles.'
Laurent Lafitte makes a proud king, Louis Garrel a thoughtful Robespierre. But the film is most enlivened by the actors playing working class rebels: Olivier Gourmet as a glassblower; Adèle Haenel, a washerwoman who loses a child through malnutrition and becomes a strong advocate for women's rights; and Céline Sallette, whose singing rouses both her character's comrades and the film itself.
Despite the copious dialogue, this could easily confound anyone without a strong grasp of French history. Yet, with its themes of national identity and the empowerment of women, it couldn't be timelier.
Selected release from Fri 25 Jan.