List Film

Ken Wardrop's documentary His & Hers suffers from lack of scope (2 stars)

comments
His & Hers

(U) 83min

His & Hers is an attractively filmed, yet narrowly focused documentary that attempts to create a snapshot of a single life of a woman in the Irish Midlands. Director Ken Wardrop knits together more than 60 interviews with women aged between 5 and 90, beginning at birth and progressing to old age, to paint a collective portrait. Whilst he shows a flair for composing attractive shots from everyday subject matter, the overall picture created by His & Hers is strangely outdated and at odds with contemporary times.

The film builds up an archaic idea of the path a woman’s life takes: from discussing boyfriends as a teenager, to marriage, to the birth of a first child. Frustratingly the women talk for the most part in a flippant manner about their relationship with men and are filmed against a domestic backdrop in their own homes, occasionally doing chores such as arranging flowers or laying the table. Issues such as careers, politics, sexuality or anything particularly meaty are almost completely absent. Later on, the film reaches a certain level of poignancy when illness and loss are brought into play but for the most part His & Hers feels like an old-fashioned and limited portrayal of its subject matter.

GFT, Glasgow, 11-17 Mar

His & Hers Trailer

His & Hers

  • 2 stars
  • 2009
  • Ireland
  • U
  • Directed by: Ken Wardrop

Attractively filmed, yet narrowly focused documentary knitted together from more than 60 interviews with women aged between 5 and 90 to paint a collective portrait. The overall picture is strangely outdated and at odds with contemporary times.

Elsewhere on the web

Comments

Post a comment