- Eddie Harrison
- 12 October 2011
Risible remake of Peckinpah's 1970s revenge thriller
An early star vehicle for Dustin Hoffman, Sam Peckinpah’s film of Gordon Williams’ novel The Siege of Trencher’s Farm was one of the high (or low) watermarks of early 1970s brutalism – a moody, nihilistic polemic that equated violence with manhood, backed up with the repellent suggestion that women might enjoy the experience of being raped. Now hack Rod Lurie has directed a near shot-for-shot remake, right down to the identical poster art, but shorn of the potent meanings of the original.
Reset to a bland Deep South setting, wimpy LA screenwriter David Sumner (James Marsden) and wife Amy (Kate Bosworth) move out to the Mississippi sticks to rebuild an old property, only to fall foul of the local yobs, led by Amy’s ex Charlie (Alexander Skarsgard). When David is lured out on a hunting trip, Charlie’s band of high-school jocks make their move on Amy, leading David to take his bloody revenge.
Love it or hate it, the original film at least reflected Sam Peckinpah’s own nihilistic kill-or-be-killed outlook. The 2011 version of Straw Dogs is a bland, soulless confection, devoid of cultural resonance, and a waste of time for cast, crew and audience alike.
General release from Fri 4 Nov.