List Film

13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi (1 star)

Michael Bay’s obnoxious actioner takes a characteristically crude look at a true-life tragedy

comments (2)
13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi

With 13 Hours, Michael Bay doesn’t so much wear his political heart on his sleeve as use it to beat his audience into submission. His dramatic retelling of the 2012 terrorist attack on US diplomats in Benghazi, Libya plays like an extended Republican Party election broadcast, complete with relentless handheld camera carnage and beating jungle drum soundtrack.

During the endless set-up, we see security contractors Jack Silva and Tyrone Woods (the ever-brilliant John Krasinski and James Badge Dale) join a team of fellow ex-army men at a secret CIA compound in Benghazi. They are, as we are repeatedly reminded, normal family men, risking it all to bring democracy and prosperity to Libyan society.

Instead of attempting to mine the fascinating depths of the attack – the subject of an investigation after Republicans accused President Obama of failing to act – Bay has taken his normal approach, eschewing narrative nuance for shaky camerawork, hokey slow-motion and explosive effects. Similarly, in adapting the book by Mitchell Zuckoff, screenwriter Chuck Hogan has reduced these soldiers to clichéd war-machines who spout lines like, ‘As long as I’m doing the right thing, God will protect me.’ While machismo surely runs high in extreme situations, here it plays like contrived political posturing.

Sadly, the real-life women involved in this situation are all but ignored. Only one has a small speaking role, Alexia Barlier’s agent Sona Jillani, and she is introduced as a ‘spicy bitch’, told repeatedly to shut up because, as one soldier puts it, ‘I need your eyes and your ears, not your mouth,’ and falls down some steps as she delivers refreshments. While war stories are, traditionally, a masculine domain, such unbridled misogyny is unwarranted and unforgivable.

The same can be said for its rampaging racism. Bay plays fast and loose with Libyan loss of life and, while the characterisation on the US-side may be ham-fisted, it is non-existent elsewhere. The film views all non-Americans with total suspicion: ‘They are all bad guys until they’re not,’ intones a soldier, one of many over-simplified sentiments that, while likely reflecting the truth of the situation, sound like they have been ripped straight out a Donald Trump campaign speech. There is a brief scene in which Libyan women are seen mourning their dead, although this is almost immediately replaced by a lingering shot of a ruined American flag surrounded by debris.

There is absolutely no doubt that men and women who spend their days on the frontlines of conflict deserve universal respect and admiration, but reducing their endeavours to a jingoistic, Bayhem-fuelled actioner is no way to honour them. Election-year conservative fearmongering masquerading as cinema, 13 Hours does a disservice both to its excellent cast and the heroic individuals they portray.

General release from Fri 29 Jan.

13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi

  • 1 star
  • 2016
  • US
  • 144 min
  • 15
  • Directed by: Michael Bay
  • Cast: John Krasinski, James Badge Dale, Pablo Schreiber

Dramatic retelling of the 2012 attack by Islamic militants on US diplomats in Benghazi. Good actors are wasted in this worthless extended Republican Party election broadcast, which eschews nuance, interest in non-Americans, respect for women and basic humanity in favour of shaky camerawork, jingoism, unbridled misogyny…

Comments

1. Jack Maxwell26 Jan 2016, 5:34pm Report

Wow, talk about your your slavishly politically-correct progressive media! I thought all the press "party organs" disappeared with the old Soviet Union. In Orwell's nightmare vision of a Marxist dominated world, the "Minister of Truth" spent all it's time re-writing facts to confirm to the party's narrative, just like this hack-job, joke of a review, touches on all the progressive talking points concerning, women, Muslims, and war junkie military types. The trouble is, this film, according to the men who were there and who were closely involved with the production, it reflected the true reality of what happened. Unless of course, you believe these men who were willing to sacrifice their last full measure of devotion to save lives are all liars. If you are willing to buy into this, what was their motivation? The safe thing would have been to stand down and use "Bob's" order as justification. And speaking of denying the truth, looking from afar at Europe, we see how progressive wishful thinking has conditioned Europeans to ignore another reality, the true danger of swarming their homeland with a violent, intolerant, oppressive, supremacist religion. The appeal of leftism is in it's ability to make you feel morally and intellectually superior, and it works until reality comes up and bites you in the rear.

2. Armando Lopez26 Jan 2016, 9:11pm Report

Jack Maxwell you are spot on.

This person clearly didn't watch the interviews of the surviving contractor or read the book, which contained no made up dialogue.

She is just upset that the movie doesn't fit with her agenda and her perception of reality.

Basically Nikki, you have zero business reviewing films.

Post a comment
RSS feed of these comments